Purpose clauses: can lenders claim breach of trust?

Download document:

Purpose clauses: can lenders claim breach of trust? - .PDF file.

In most facility agreements, lenders include a clause that the loan can only be used for a specific purpose, for example, to assist with the costs of development of a property. In the rare cases where funds are used for another purpose (often in cases of fraud), lenders may attempt to claim that the purpose clause creates a trust in their favour. The advantage for the lender in establishing a trust is that the funds transferred remain the property of the lender unless the borrower applies them for the agreed specified purpose.

In the Gabriel v Little and others case, the High Court considered whether the borrower received loan monies as a trustee pursuant to a purpose clause whereby the loan was to be used for the development of a property.

It was found that the trust was not created. The fact that the purpose clause did not state that the loan had to be used for the sole or exclusive purpose of development of the property did not in itself prevent a trust from being created, but the absence of these words could be material. Additionally, a wide range of matters could be considered to be “development” and, therefore, there was too much uncertainty to create a trust…

If you are registered and logged in to the site, click on the link below to read the rest of the Shoosmiths briefing. If not, please register or sign in with your details below.