Time at the bar
21 April 2005
Misery, it seems, is the defining characteristic of Harry Mounts experience of pupillage. During our lunch, references to his time at the bar are rarely made without the words misery and miserable popping up. But despite his awful time, Mounts book on his life as a pupil is a hugely amusing account. It is only when you talk to Mount, now deputy comment editor of The Daily Telegraph, that you realise quite how dark those days were and detect more than a hint of bitterness.
I had an absolutely miserable year, the worst year ever, and it was a waste. When Im about to die, Ill look back and say that was a wasted year, he says matter-of-factly.
In short and the book is short with 170 pages in large type My Brief Career: The Trials of a Young Lawyer, details Mounts experiences of the pupillage system at two chambers. To avoid the attentions of the libel lawyers, the characters are composites of many of the people he met at the bar, but everything that takes place is based on real incidents.
As well as finding the work dull, he suffered at the hands of his first pupilmaster David Frobisher. Mounts exchanges, or lack of exchanges, with Frobisher are painfully funny and at times just painful. Frobisher, for reasons best known to him, is totally indifferent to Mount and makes no effort to speak to him or to tutor him in becoming a barrister, saying only the bare minimum to Mount when absolutely necessary.
Complete silence for three months and not a single bit of training, muses Mount. Its absolutely staggering.
Meanwhile, fellow pupil Silas Thorburn has to endure Alec McArdle, a traditional bully, who on one particularly nasty occasion makes Thorburn stand in front of a window for a whole morning to block the sun from his computer.
As a result of his experiences and those of others, Mount would like to see an overhaul of the pupillage system. The book is supposed to entertain, but theres a serious point, he says. The system is badly put together. Its fine to be put with someone whos nice and good and considerate, but the way its done allows for a terrible disaster if you get a bad pupilmaster.
Mount says there are badly behaved people in all walks of life and barristers are no worse than anyone else. However, the solitary relationship between pupil and pupilmaster means problems stay within the confines of the room and can go largely unchecked. You can go and complain to a senior person in chambers, but youve got this year and youre desperately trying to get the job and you think complaining is going to be a suicide note, he says.
Mount also rails against the year-long interview nature of pupillage. I cant see why they dont make the decision when you apply. Its a nice luxury for them to see what youre like, but I think its a really cruel thing to put people through.
By that stage youve gone to university, done the conversion in my case, then bar school, that should be enough to go on. If it turns out theyre the wrong person for the job then sack them and employ someone new.
Mounts advice to wannabe barristers is to know what you are getting yourself into. No one ever tells you that most of what lawyers do is go through mind-numbingly boring documents checking for spelling mistakes, he says.
Go and do a mini-pupillage, or several, Mount urges. Ask yourself if youre really interested in the work and, if you find that you prefer to read a newspaper or read a book than a law report, then maybe reconsider.
I think there are some people who are cut out for it, but dont do it because its highly paid and your mother wants you to.
Mount has little time for the various odd conventions surrounding the bar. In the book he is obviously unimpressed by rules such as not shaking hands with fellow barristers and not being allowed to read during lunch, while he expresses incredulity that he was banned from visiting the loo during his first dinner. Yet Mount is no stranger to tradition; he attended public school the prestigious Westminster School whose origins date back to 1179 and read ancient and modern history at Magdalen College, Oxford.
Im all for old-fashioned things, he says. I like people having good manners and I like old-fashioned things, but only if theyre used to make people have a nicer time. If theyre used to humiliate people or make people ill at ease, it clearly defeats the point of them.
Lunching in Canary Wharf all brand-spanking new buildings gleaming with the glass and metal that seems a prerequisite for offices these days feels a lifetime away from the chambers where Mount had his annus horribilis. Although the Inns of Court are just half an hour away on public transport, in terms of working practices and atmosphere, somewhere like The Daily Telegraph is a world away. Mount has moved from warren-like chambers where he shared a room with his pupilmaster to the kind of open-plan office structure favoured by editorial teams. He admits that he is not overly keen on being in one big office in this way, but notes with interest the sub-cultures that have developed on different parts of the newspaper the trendy fashion writers contrast sharply with his team who tend to be suited and booted.
In so many ways, Mount should have been suited to bar life. Theres an illuminating part of the book where he is able to quote Latin to one of the barristers, unlike the working-class Thorburn, yet at the end of his pupillage he was unable to secure a tenancy. He says that when it came down to it, he wasnt cut out for the job. Mount had good pupilmasters after Frobisher, but he still felt the job was tedious and squeezed the life out of anything interesting, so his dislike of the work affected his performance.
Theres a story about Derry Irvine, that when he was young and keen on drink, however drunk he got as a law student, when he got home and got into bed hed read that days law reports. That is the extreme example of what I wasnt, he says.
But he is and always has been an avid reader of newspapers. When he graduated from university, his father, once a big noise on The Times Literary Supplement, secured him a few book reviews and this gave him a taster of journalism.
Since that initial break, he has written reviews and articles for a range of magazines and newspapers of all political hues from The Guardian to The Spectator before landing a staff job in 2000 on The Daily Telegraph.
He is clearly loving his new role and a previously unheard-of enthusiasm and relaxed tone creeps into his voice as he describes his typical day, which involves editing the work of the papers columnists, such as flamboyant MP Boris Johnson and television presenter Anne Robinson, and writing the papers leader columns. His initial passion for law has not completely diminished today it has emerged that the Northern Ireland Assembly wants to punish Sinn Fein leaders for violence by the provisional IRA and Mount is wondering whether this is legally possible but the career path he has chosen is where he belongs.
Contrary to popular belief, journalism is quite lowly paid, but Mount says that the fat salary he could have earned at the bar would be no compensation for his current job satisfaction. I dont wake up at five or six in the morning with my heart thumping with misery. You cant put a price on that, he says.
He adds: If youve got the luxury of doing something enjoyable, that gives you enough to survive on, and you know what that job is, then youd be mad not to do it.
My Brief Career - The Trials of a Young Lawyer is published by Short Books at 9.99
Excerpt from My Brief Career
Using pupils practically
I copied down a passage from Anna Karenina: There are no conditions of life to which a man cannot accustom himself, especially if he sees that everyone around him lives in the same way.
I felt this particularly keenly when I compared notes with Silas.
One lunchtime, he knocked gingerly on my door.
Silas was pale and tight-lipped. Once hed seen that David wasnt in the room, he pulled his chair over towards mine.
Has David left for lunch?
Yes. Whats wrong?
His face relaxed for a moment.
Alec has really gone too far. This morning this morning, he
Silas took several deep breaths and tried to speak but couldnt, without his voice breaking. He raised his eyes to the ceiling.
Dont be sorry. Cry if you want.
He didnt say anything for a while. I went and got him a glass of water. By the time I got back, hed composed himself.
When I came in this morning, Alec asked me to come over to his desk and help him with something.
What about the exclusion zone?
Well, exactly. I thought something quite good must be about to happen if he was prepared to let me come within a yard of him.
Id just got inside the exclusion zone, when he said, Stop. Stand there and dont move.
Oh come on, Silas. Im sorry to sound harsh, but you cant get too upset. Youve known about the exclusion zone for months.
Yes, but that wasnt it this time. Hes never got me to stand on the edge of the zone before. I asked him what he wanted me to do and he just said: Stand there. No, just a little bit to your right. Forward a bit. There. Thats perfect. Now, just move a little to your left every minute or so parallel to the window frame whenever I say left.
Well, that doesnt sound too bad. What did he do next?
Nothing. Just kept me moving bit by bit. He was making me into a sunshade for his computer screen. For the whole morning, Ive been a fucking sundial, slowly moving round the room.
He choked these last words out and, for the first time, cried a little.
Oh God, Silas. That is terrible, I said. Whenever I heard his horror stories before, I felt a little relief the worse they were, the better my chances of tenancy. I hardly felt that at all this time.
You must complain. You cant go back in there this afternoon.
No, I cant complain. You know I cant. Anyway, this afternoon wont be so bad.
His room is east-facing.