Report this comment to a moderator

QC appointments slip to all time low with 84 made up

The Silk appointments system is no longer a good determinant of ability. The system has been "cracked" by consultants who tell candidates what to put on their forms; they then pretty much guarantee success. If the QCA are to retain any credibility then they must introduce an examination filter; as is now universally used for appointments to Recorder and Deputy District Judge. In terms of numbers, it is telling that the Hong Kong Bar which is about 15% of the size of the English Bar, only recruits 3 Silks each year. If QC is to remain a badge of excellence urgent reform is needed.

27-Feb-2013

10:40 am