Scottish court applies tenderer test to assessing procurement award criteria

For public authorities struggling with mounting challenges to tenders and increasingly stringent transparency requirements, a recent, common-sense ruling by the Scottish Court of Session is likely provide some relief. On 21 March 2013, the court dismissed an action to set aside the award of a framework agreement by the Common Services Agency for the Scottish Health Service (CSA) on the grounds that the award criteria lacked sufficient clarity. In doing so, the court had to consider the appropriate test to determine whether the award criteria sufficiently met the obligations for transparency and equal treatment. The court concluded that the award criteria must allow ‘all reasonably well-informed and normally diligent tenderers to interpret the criteria in the same way’.

In 2010, the CSA invited tenders for a single-supplier framework agreement to provide certain breast cancer treatment drugs (Tastuzumab) and nursing services to patients in their homes. One of the bidders, Healthcare at Home Limited (HAH), had been providing the services under an earlier contract but lost the bid to a competitor, BUPA. HAH challenged the decision on the basis that the award criteria set out in the Invitation to Tender (ITT) lacked clarity and consequently breached the obligations of equal treatment and transparency under the procurement rules. On 1 May 2012, in a first instance ruling, a commercial judge of the Outer House of the Scottish Court of Session dismissed the claims leading HAH to appeal to the Inner House of the Court of Session…

If you are registered and logged in to the site, click on the link below to read the rest of the Nabarro briefing. If not, please register or sign in with your details below.

 

Briefings from Nabarro

View more briefings from Nabarro

Analysis from The Lawyer

  • pro neg

    Professional negligence: Claims vs reality

    Clients are more willing to bring claims against professional service providers but the risk to defendants is not as dramatic as it might seem 

  • Google HQ

    Number crunching: Nabarro’s real estate

    Real estate continues to be the key money spinner for Nabarro, which has always been known for its work in the UK property market, (although) last year results were up across the firm.  Google’s ...

View more analysis from The Lawyer

Overview

Lacon House
84 Theobald's Road
London
WC1X 8RW
UK
http://www.nabarro.com

Turnover (£m): 116.30
No. of Lawyers: 360