Competition: European Commission cannot conduct a ‘fishing expedition’ during a dawn raid
In two recent judgments, the European General Court (the General Court) has provided insight into the vexed question of just how far a competition authority can go when it carries out a “dawn raid” of business premises during a cartel investigation. The judgments confirm that the European Commission is not entitled to go on a “fishing expedition” when conducting a dawn raid. It must limit its inspection to activities where there is a suspicion of infringement. It cannot use the opportunity to search premises for documents relating to all company activities.
The General Court reached this conclusion on 14 November 2012, in response to legal challenges (cases T-135/09 and T-140/09) by two companies, Nexans and Prysmian, in relation to an investigation into the electrical cables sector.
In January 2009, Nexans and Prysmian were ordered to submit to an inspection in relation to the supply of electrical cables and materials including high-voltage underwater electric cables and high-voltage underground electric cables…
If you are registered and logged in to the site, click on the link below to read the rest of the Nabarro briefing. If not, please register or sign in with your details below.
Click on the link above to download briefing.
News from Nabarro
Briefings from Nabarro
Because of a history of litigation between a landlord and its tenants, the landlord was justified in refusing to grant the tenants a new business lease.
In a recent case, it was the tenant of certain floors and the car park in an office building where it paid service charge calculated by deducting the annual expenditure from the gross annual expenditure.
Analysis from The Lawyer
Nabarro senior partner and self-confessed “IT geek” Graham Stedman is heralding a major set of investments in technology ahead of the firm’s move to 125 London Wall this year.
Clients are more willing to bring claims against professional service providers but the risk to defendants is not as dramatic as it might seem