The Lawyer Africa Elite 2014 features an in-depth look at 46 leading independent firms’ strategies in 15 key sub-Saharan jurisdictions, as well as the views of in-house counsel from some of Africa’s largest companies... Read more
This year, The Lawyer’s annual ranking of the largest UK law firms by turnover is available as an interactive, digital benchmarking tool. For the first time this will allow you to manipulate each data set against the metrics of your choice.
For Peoplesoft, Cleary Gottlieb Steen & Hamilton has ousted Gibson Dunn & Crutcher, thanks to a recommendation from antitrust crusader and Microsoft nemesis Gary Reback of Carr & Ferrell.
Reback told The Lawyer: “[Oracle chief executive officer] Larry Ellison was making a big noise with securities analysts saying that he is doing what Microsoft was doing. Microsoft dominates the desktop and he wants to dominate the back office. I rang Peoplesoft and said ‘I want to help’.”
After his titanic battles with Microsoft, Reback was taking time out of the law. He had launched technology company Voxeo and was writing a book when he heard Ellison’s comments and decided on a return to the fray.
Reback, who called Cleary Gottlieb partner Mark Leddy for assistance, said: “The company had a relationship with Gibson Dunn & Crutcher. They were doing [the antitrust work] but we phased them out.”
Gibson Dunn partner Doug Smith continues to advise Peoplesoft on the corporate aspects of the deal. Linklaters is advising on EU competition issues.
Oracle’s hostile $9.3bn (£5.09bn) bid for Peoplesoft has sparked a litigation frenzy with Davis Polk & Wardwell fighting Peoplesoft’s ‘poison pill’ shareholders’ rights plan in Delaware. Gibson Dunn and Cleary are defending Peoplesoft’s defensive tactic.
The attention has since turned to San Francisco after the Department of Justice filed to block the merger, saying that the takeover would reduce competition in the enterprise software market, which is dominated by the two US companies and Germany’s SAP.
“The Government surprised them in San Francisco and Dan Wall [of Latham] was called in,” said Reback. Howrey Simon’s Jim Rill and Steve Smith of Morrison & Foerster had been arguing Peoplesoft’s case in Washington DC and Oracle turned to Latham for the first time when West Coast litigation strength was required.