Debentures — a ‘new’ meaning? Fons Hf v Corporal Ltd and another

A familiar requirement of secured credit is for the customer to provide a debenture, which is commonly understood as meaning security over the customer’s business and assets. However, a recent decision — Fons Hf v Corporal Ltd and another [2014] EWCA 304 — highlighted an older and wider meaning of debenture: any document that creates or acknowledges a debt (and not just one creating security). A somewhat unusual twist was given to this wider meaning by the Court of Appeal in the case in question.

A company (Topco) had granted a charge over the shares in its subsidiary (Subco) in favour of Topco’s bank. The charge defined the ‘shares’ charged as including ‘…all shares, debentures… and other securities owned by Topco in Subco… or in which it has an interest’. As a shareholder in Subco, Topco made certain loans to Subco, although the bank was not initially aware of them. When the bank came to take legal action, the repayment rights of Topco under these loans were worth more than the charged shares in Subco…

Click on the link below to read the rest of the Gateley briefing.

Briefings from Gateley

View more briefings from Gateley

Analysis from The Lawyer

Overview

111 Edmund Street
Birmingham
B3 2HJ
UK
http://www.gateleyuk.com/news-and-events/social-media/

Turnover (£m): 66.00
No. of Lawyers: 372