The Lawyer Asia Pacific 150 is the only research report to provide a ranking of the top 100 independent local firms and top 50 global firms in the region. The report offers critical review of some of the fastest growing firms and their strategies, a country-by-country guide to leading legal advisers and legal services market trends, plus exclusive insight into the current business development opportunities in the Asia Pacific. Read more
This year, The Lawyer’s annual ranking of the largest UK law firms by turnover is available as an interactive, digital benchmarking tool. For the first time this will allow you to manipulate each data set against the metrics of your choice.
DLA senior partner Roger Lane-Smith failed to record a meeting in which the chairman of JJB Sports Dave Whelan was found to have rigged the price of football shirts with his competitors, David Hughes of all:sports and Mike Ashley of Sports Soccer.
Lane-Smith is a non-executive director of JJB, which was fined £8.37m by the Office of Fair Trading (OFT) last August for illegal retail price-fixing.
Manchester United FC, Umbro, the Football Association and others were also found guilty, but all:sports and JJB appealed their case to the Competition Appeals Tribunal (CAT).
The CAT found that, contrary to his evidence, Whelan had discussed prices at the meeting of 8 June 2000 at Hughes’s house, at which Lane-Smith was not present.
At a later board meeting attended by Lane-Smith, it was agreed that he would record Whelan’s description of what had happened at the Hughes meeting – given at the board meeting – in a private note. Another witness gave evidence that this was in order that any note should attract legal privilege.
According to Lane-Smith’s evidence, he “overlooked” recording it. The CAT, which upheld the OFT’s decision, said in its judgment: “We are surprised that no record of any kind apparently exists.” The tribunal added that the minutes would not, in its view, have attracted legal privilege in any event.
Lane-Smith said: “The OFT didn’t challenge it [his evidence] and, had they done so, I would have been more than happy to go into the witness box.”
An OFT spokesperson declined to comment.
Details of a diary kept by Hughes also emerged during the appeal. In an entry scored out in three colours of biro, it said: “Agree Man United and England prices with everybody.”
In another, scored out with marker pen but revealed by forensic examination, it said: “Phone Mike Ashley to review Man United [kit] launch and other issues.”
JJB finance director David Greenwood said the company was considering a further appeal and called the CAT’s decision “perverse”.
A spokesperson for all:sports said: “all:sports is currently reviewing the judgment and exploring all its options.”
With regard to the diary entries, he said: “all:sports disagrees with the tribunal’s conclusions. The full and innocent explanation was set out in its ‘post-closing observations’, responding to late submissions by the OFT.”