When can experts assist the court in procurement disputes?
The procurement of major infrastructure projects is long and complex, costing millions. Bidders routinely instruct consultants to provide expertise on technical matters, pricing and turning each proposal into a viable, attractive and cost effective submission. Public authorities likewise instruct expert consultants to evaluate bids. With so much at stake, not least huge sums of public money, the role of experts can be crucial. It would therefore seem obvious that when major litigation emerges from a procurement, the parties should be able to rely on expert evidence in support of their case.
Not so. In the case of By Development Ltd and Ors -v- Covent Garden Market Authority, the Court concluded that the Claimants should not rely on expert evidence in support of claims that the Defendant public authority had committed manifest errors in the assessment of bids.
The case involved the major redevelopment of the “new” Covent Garden site in South London, where the market has operated for nearly 40 years. The Claimants’ bid was unsuccessful. They issued proceedings claiming that the authority’s evaluation of the bids contained manifest errors, particularly on planning matters. The Court refused permission for expert evidence on planning and financial issues…
If you are registered and logged in to the site, click on the link below to read the rest of the Addleshaw Goddard briefing. If not, please register or sign in with your details below.
Click on the link above to download briefing.
News from Addleshaw Goddard
News from The Lawyer
Briefings from Addleshaw Goddard
The Supreme Court in Coventry v Lawrence has altered the approach that courts will take when considering whether to grant injunctive relief or damages.
Data & Information E-Alerts — nuisance calls action plan; £50,000 fine for unlawful calls; simpler security classifications; and more
Addleshaw Goddard has released the 4 April 2014 edition of its Data & Information E-Alerts publication.
Analysis from The Lawyer
Could Slater & Gordon achieve its stated aim of becoming a top consumer brand by acquiring Pannone?
The past five years have not been easy for Addleshaw Goddard. The firm’s revenue fell 7 per cent from £173.1m to £161.9m between 2008/09 and 2010/11 and despite finances looking up in 2011/12, when Addleshaws reported a 30 per cent increase in net profit, it has shown no notable compound growth in turnover since 2007/08.