Taxing multinationals, and the public accounts committee: is there a place for common sense?
Following the sessions of the public accounts committee with Google and the HMRC, many commentators remain uncomfortable that US multinationals with significant UK operations can legitimately claim not to be taxable in the UK.
The committee itself was clearly puzzled that evidence given to it by ‘whistleblowers’ did not fatally undermine Google’s own position. Answering criticism last week that the committee does not understand the underlying tax principles well enough, Mrs Hodge challenged tax professionals to explain in ‘common-sense’ terms why the ‘anger’ felt by members of the committee and the public was misplaced. So here goes.
The question the committee was wrestling with is how it can be possible that an organisation that conducts sales activities in the UK, with UK customers and using UK employees, is not taxable on the profits from those sales. The answer is that it is, but in a way that reflects the division of activities between the UK business and the business elsewhere…
If you are registered and logged in to the site, click on the link below to read the rest of the Allen & Overy briefing. If not, please register or sign in with your details below.
News from Allen & Overy
News from The Lawyer
Briefings from Allen & Overy
Sylvia Kierszenbaum and Willem Van de Wiele have authored an article in The International Capital Markets Review.
The Provincial Court of Madrid has upheld a hybrid dispute resolution clause. The judgment is the first one in Spain that recognises the validity of hybrid arbitration clauses.
Analysis from The Lawyer
Advisers get stuck into the disentangling task, to unhitch troubled bank from group
Shell legal director Peter Rees is switching litigation control away from external counsel to a unified global team of in-housers