Supreme Court Corner — Q2 2014: Octane Fitness v Icon Health & Fitness; Limelight Networks v Akamai Techs; and more
By Stan Panikowski, Brian Biggs, Jeremy T Elman and Andrew N Stein
Octane Fitness LLC v Icon Health & Fitness Inc. Patent: Decided: 29 April 2014
Holding: a patent case is ‘exceptional’ under 35 USC § 285 when it ‘stands out from others with respect to the substantive strength of a party’s litigating position or the unreasonable manner in which the case was litigated’.
This decision overturns the Brooks Furniture Mfg v Dutalier Int’l Inc standard, finding instead that awarding fees is a matter of discretion and should be evaluated case by case. The court noted ‘exceptional’ is not defined in § 285 and found exceptional means ‘uncommon’, ‘rare’ or ‘not ordinary’, rejecting the prior two-prong standard as ‘overly rigid’. The Court held a party could satisfy § 285’s ‘exceptional’ requirement by showing an infringement claim is ‘simply one that stands out from others with respect to the substantive strength of a party’s litigating position (both the governing law and the facts of the case) or the unreasonable manner in which the case was litigated’.
This opinion is being widely read as lowering the standard for attorney fee awards. However, in the first opinion applying Octane – Bianco v Globus Medical, Inc, the Eastern District of Texas did not award fees because the defendant did not meet its burden of proof. Interestingly, Federal Circuit judge William C Bryson was sitting by designation and authored the opinion…
Click on the link below to read the rest of the DLA Piper briefing.
News from DLA Piper
News from The Lawyer
Briefings from DLA Piper
Social media is an ever-increasing area of litigation. Facebook users spend more than 10.5 billion minutes per day on the website, for example.
The OIG Compendium provides a summary of opportunities to ‘achieve cost savings, improve programme management and ensure quality of care and safety of beneficiaries.’
Analysis from The Lawyer
Regulators are ramping up the pressure in the aftermath of recession, leaving firms to compete for compliance and restructuring work
Shearman & Sterling is making its presence felt in the City, squaring up to magic circle firms and looking to muscle in on key relationships. Private equity house Bridgepoint is one outfit that has had its head turned by the US firm.