Schütz v Werit — replacing parts in patented products

This recent patent decision of the Supreme Court provides guidance about when replacing a part might be treated as the infringing act of ‘making’ a patented product. This may be relevant when considering repairs, spares and refills, for example. The case related to industrial containers for transporting liquid in a plastic bottle surrounded by a metal cage on a pallet. The relevant claim in Schütz’s patent covered the container as a whole — listing features of the bottle, cage and pallet together — although the inventive aspects were only in the cage. Werit reconditioned containers by removing the used bottles and providing new replacements. Did this amount to ‘making’ the patented container?

The Supreme Court said the patent claim must identify the replacement part as a feature of the patented product and it is also necessary to consider a number of factors, including whether the replaced part: 

  • is a freestanding, easily replaceable component of the patented product (if not, that counts in the patent-owner’s favour);
  • includes, or has connection with, any aspect of the claimed inventive concept of the patented product (if so, that counts in the patent-owner’s favour);
  • is a main or subsidiary part of the patented product (if a main part, that counts in the patentowner’s favour); and
  • has a shorter life expectancy than the product as a whole and its replacement would be anticipated by customers (if not, that counts in the patent-owner’s favour)…

If you are registered and logged in to the site, click on the link below to read the rest of the Taylor Wessing briefing. If not, please register or sign in with your details below.

Briefings from Taylor Wessing

View more briefings from Taylor Wessing

Analysis from The Lawyer

  • merger deal

    Corporate crunch time: who will triumph at The Lawyer Awards 2014?

    As the equity capital markets rocketed back into favour and global M&A saw at least a partial return to form, there have been some rich pickings for The Lawyer’s Corporate Team of the Year award shortlisted firms in 2014. 

  • singapore orchid

    Singapore: Cash course

    The city-state is working hard to become a global wealth management hub, and law firms are gearing up for a prosperous new world

View more analysis from The Lawyer

Overview

5 New Street Square
London
EC4A 3TW
UK
http://www.taylorwessing.com

Turnover (£m): 241.20
No. of lawyers: 860 (UK 200)
Jurisdiction: UK
No. of offices: 4
No. of qualified lawyers: 67 (International 50)

Jobs