Penalty clauses in commercial agreements: El Makdessi v Cavendish Square Holdings
By Rebecca Gardner and Zachary Brown
It is common for parties to commercial agreements to agree mechanisms for resolving breaches of their agreement without having to resort to legal proceedings. Typically this is done by incorporating provisions, such as forfeiture or compulsory buy-back clauses, into a contract, which are activated upon one party’s breach of its terms.
In such a situation, it is important for the parties to ensure that such provisions could not be characterised as penalties so as to render them unenforceable. This issue was considered in the case of El Makdessi v Cavendish Square Holdings BV and another *2013+ EWCA Civ 1539, where the Court of Appeal was asked to review an earlier decision by the High Court on the question of whether clauses in a share purchase agreement (SPA), which were activated in response to the seller’s breach of restrictive covenant, constituted unenforceable penalties.
It is a long-established rule of law that a clause that is deemed to be a penalty will be unenforceable. In determining whether a clause is a penalty, the courts often use liquidated damages clauses (which are enforceable) as a point of comparison…
Click on the link below to read the rest of the Goodman Derrick briefing.
News from Goodman Derrick
Briefings from Goodman Derrick
This briefing provides an explanation of how the new flexible working regime will work, along with some advice for employers on how to minimise the risks of litigation.
A new Competition and Markets Authority: but no new dawn for the public competition law enforcement in the UK
With a certain amount of trumpeting, the new Competition and Markets Authority came into existence on 1 April — thus merging the OFT and the Competition Commission.
Analysis from The Lawyer
The lure of the law can kick in at any stage of life. We speak to four individuals who have made a radical switch to a legal career
You don’t have to be a big firm to innovate and thrive in a downturn, as our look at the lower half of the UK 200 shows. We pick 10 inspiring stories