Wragge Lawrence Graham & Co

UK 200 2013 position: 25

Harrison, PPI and unfair relationship revisited

The Court of Appeal has revisited the issue of unfair relationship in payment protection insurance (PPI) claims where the payment of commission was not disclosed.

The two conjoined appeals were Plevin v Paragon Personal Finance Ltd and Conlon v Black Horse Ltd. Conlon argued that her claim could be distinguished from Harrison as the court had accepted that had she been aware of the commission she would have searched for cheaper insurance. In Plevin, the argument was that there were serious failings in the broker’s assessment of the policy’s suitability and that the broker’s conduct was ‘on behalf of’ and so bound the lender.

The Court of Appeal held that Conlon’s case was indistinguishable from Harrison. It did not accept the fact that Conlon would have looked for cheaper insurance had she known of the commission as a relevant distinction. In Harrison, it was held that it would be anomalous if a lender could be found to have created an unfair relationship where there was no breach of the relevant regulatory regime…

If you are registered and logged in to the site, click on the link below to read the rest of the Wragge & Co briefing. If not, please register or sign in with your details below.

Briefings from Wragge Lawrence Graham & Co

View more briefings from Wragge Lawrence Graham & Co

Analysis from The Lawyer

  • Paul Wilson

    Regional: attempted merger

    Alliances, failed and successful, are the story of the year outside London

  • Belinda Bradberry

    Interior designs

    Polish up your retention policy - private practice lawyers are increasingly eyeing in-house roles

View more analysis from The Lawyer


2 Snowhill
B4 6WR

Turnover (£m): 120.50
No. of Lawyers: 458