Evolving case law on the fair use of famous trademarks in video games
By Sean F Kane
A recent spate of cases has generally upheld, on First Amendment grounds, a developer’s right to include unlicensed trademarks in video games. However, until the body of case law becomes so prevalent that trademark owners recognise that they cannot possibly succeed in an action involving use in a video game, it may be wise for developers to be circumspect in what they include. In many cases, the costs of licensing a trademark may be much less than demonstrating rights under the First Amendment
In some of today’s top-grossing video game titles, realism is a key component to the success of the game. In order to promote authenticity, many of the leading publishers incorporate the names, images and trademarks of famous brands into the video games. While many of the brands have historically agreed to the inclusion of their marks, more and more video game publishers are including trademarks in their games without the owner’s express authorisation.
For instance, in early May 2013, Electronic Arts issued a statement saying it will no longer be entering into licensing agreements with gun manufacturers but that it retains the right to continue to feature branded guns in EA games. ‘We’re telling a story and we have a point of view,’ EA’s president of labels Frank Gibeau said in an interview. ‘A book doesn’t pay for saying the word “Colt”, for example.’ Put another way, EA is asserting its First Amendment…
If you are registered and logged in to the site, click on the link below to read the rest of the Pillsbury briefing. If not, please register or sign in with your details below.
News from Pillsbury Winthrop Shaw Pittman
News from The Lawyer
Briefings from Pillsbury Winthrop Shaw Pittman
Ninth Circuit eliminates presumption of irreparable injury for plaintiffs seeking preliminary injunctions in trademark cases
The Ninth Circuit has ruled that a trademark plaintiff must establish a likelihood of irreparable harm to obtain a preliminary injunction in a trademark case.
Co-head of Pillsbury’s energy industry team, Robert A James, authored this chapter in the publication The Oil and Gas Law Review.