Early disclosure of evaluation documents in public procurement dispute

In Roche Diagnostics Ltd v Mid Yorkshire Hospitals NHS Trust [2013] EWHC 933 (TCC), an unsuccessful tenderer was entitled to both specific and pre-action disclosure in a public procurement dispute in relation to two related contracts. Coulson J provides important guidance on how the courts will approach early applications for disclosure in public procurement disputes.

The claimant, Roche Diagnostics Ltd, and the defendant, the Mid Yorkshire Hospitals NHS Trust, were involved in a public procurement dispute in relation to the letting of a managed service contract (MSC) for the provision of laboratory services at three hospitals.

After discovering that it had been unsuccessful in its bid for the MSC, the claimant asked for information relating to the evaluation process. The defendant sent through a number of spreadsheets. The documents were ‘secondary’ because they had been created after the evaluation process as a means of explaining how it had been carried out. The spreadsheets were inconsistent and contained manifest errors. Consequently, the claimant lost confidence in the evaluation process carried out by the defendant and commenced litigation proceedings…

If you are registered and logged in to the site, click on the link below to read the rest of the Allen & Overy briefing. If not, please register or sign in with your details below.

Analysis from The Lawyer

  • Panel reviews

    Panel reviews 2014: The chosen ones

    Which firms are cutting it in this era of slimline rosters, and who are the GC new brooms making clean sweeps? The Lawyer can reveal all

  • training

    Accutrainee: Revolution postponed

    At the time of its launch Accutrainee was described as a revolutionary change to the training model. Has it proved to be so? Not really.

View more analysis from The Lawyer


One Bishops Square
E1 6AD

Turnover (£m): 1,189.00
No. of lawyers: 2,304
Jurisdiction: UK
No. of offices: 11
No. of qualified lawyers: 273